• 0 Posts
  • 2 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: July 1st, 2023

help-circle
  • I haven’t read this book, but I’m pretty skeptical of how they define nonviolent resistance and what makes a revolution “successful”

    The Iranian Revolution, 1977–1979

    1. The First Palestinian Intifada, 1987–1992
    2. The Philippine People Power Movement, 1983–1986
    3. Why Civil Resistance Sometimes Fails: The Burmese Uprising, 1988–1990 Case Study Summary

    Are the revolutions they are principally utilizing, and that makes me think this book isn’t exactly the most academically honest study around.

    The Iranian revolution had battles in the streets and plenty of deadly clashes with the Shahs regime. It also led the the largest political massacre in the country’s history.

    The Philippine People Power Movement

    The yellow revolution funded militant groups, featured a helicopter attack on the president’s compound, and only didn’t devolve into a massacre of civilians because a marine commander refused to participate in the wholesale slaughter of tens of thousands of people.

    The First Palestinian Intifada

    Led to the deaths of over a thousand civilians and is a precursor the the genocide we are currently witnessing.

    The Burmese Uprising

    Started fairly similar to the Philippine uprising, except their military commanders were perfectly fine massacring civilians, with a death toll of 3k-10k people…

    I am willing to give this a read, but I would also suggest other people read “Setting Sites” by Scott Crow as a counterpoint.


  • That’s an incredibly reductionist and ahistorical explanation of how the Nazis overthrew the Weimar Republic…

    Not to mention incredibly dismissive to the thousands of people who were literally battling brown shirts in the streets of Berlin leading up to the burning of the reichstag .

    The Nazi didn’t rise to power because people had a defeatist attitude, it’s because the Nazi murdered their opposition, were perfectly fine with intimidating voters, and were backed by corporations and a significant portion of the population who blamed socialism for the economic slump of postwar Germany.

    If you truly believe this, I highly suggest reading “The Death of Democracy” by Benjamin Hett. Phone calls aren’t going to sway the opinions of someone who fundamentally doesn’t think you should be alive.